For more than a decade, personalization has been the holy grail of digital marketing. Countless projects, technologies, and budgets have been dedicated to tailoring shopping experiences. And yet, if we’re honest, it has never really delivered on its promise. Why?

There are three core reasons why personalization has failed.

1. Marketers and Consumers Want Different Things

Marketers see personalization as a way to improve targeting and make content more relevant. Consumers, however, don’t want to be targeted, they care about value. They’ll only share data if what they get in return feels worth it.

Too often, this value exchange has been overlooked. Asking for personal data without giving something useful back sets personalization projects up for failure.

A great counterexample is when a cosmetics brand builds a skin type diagnostic tool. By answering a few simple questions, a shopper discovers their skin type and learns which products are best suited to them. That’s genuine value - helping the customer understand their needs and solve a problem - while also providing the brand with data that makes recommendations more accurate.

Until marketers consistently create value-first experiences like this, personalization will continue to disappoint.

2. Privacy Regulations and the Collapse of Tracking

The second nail in personalization’s coffin has been regulation and platform changes. GDPR raised the bar on consent, while Apple’s “Ask App Not to Track” has given consumers the power to say no.

And they have. Opt-outs are now the norm, and black-hat approaches like device fingerprinting are being aggressively stamped out. Without reliable data on visitors, most personalization systems are left blind. No data means no personalization.

3. The “One Size Fits All” Trap

Finally, there’s the problem of context. Shoppers don’t arrive at websites with a single intention - they come from countless different starting points: a social post, an influencer video, an email, a social post, a paid ad.

Yet the vast majority of brands still funnel all this traffic into the same “home page” experience. That’s personalization in name only. A single destination can’t possibly reflect all the contexts that brought shoppers there.

Enter AI –But Not the Way You Think

At this point, it’s tempting to imagine AI swooping in to turbocharge personalization: faster, better and cheaper? But that’s a misconception. The next generation isn’t about doing the same old thing, only faster. It’s about doing something entirely different that solves the problem in a different way.

AI now makes it possible to generate complete storefronts dynamically, shaped by the context of the traffic source.

• If a shopper clicks from a creator’s video, the storefront not only identifies the products featured automatically, but also reflects the creator’s style, content, and tone.
• If they arrive via a brand’s organic social post, the storefront will automatically echo the imagery, copy, and mood of that post.
• If they click from an ad or an email, the storefront is built around that exact context.

This isn’t personalization in the old sense. It’s not about targeting individuals - it’s about aligning the shopping experience with the context that drove them there in the first place.

Is this valuable to consumers? Absolutely. Our research shows that 86% of online shoppers have had a recent bad experience when clicking through from social because they can’t find the product or it looks different from what was shown on social.  

The End of the Home Page as We Know It

This shift also spells the end of the “one home page” era. Instead of a single entry point that brands endlessly tweak to try to fit all audiences, there are now many entry points—each one relevant, dynamic, and context-aware.

The result? A far better experience for shoppers, who feel understood and guided, and a huge uplift for brands. We’ve seen cases where AI-driven contextual storefronts deliver up to 12x more revenue compared to sending traffic to a static home, category, or product page.

The Future Isn’t Better Personalization – It’s Something Different

So where does this leave us? The future of digital shopping doesn’t look like the old personalization model, just improved. It looks like something fundamentally different: AI-enabled, context-driven storefronts that put value and relevance first.

It’s a reminder of Henry Ford’s famous quote: “If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said faster horses.”

The future of e-commerce isn’t a faster horse called “personalization.” It’s the equivalent of invention of a new means of transport - an entirely new way of thinking about how we connect shoppers with what they came to find.

‍