Even well-known brands go unnamed in AI answers.
SimplicityDX tested well-known retailers, CPG brands, and DTC brands across 476 answers from ChatGPT and Google AI Mode. Name recognition should have helped them. Most still went unnamed, even when a creator had already made the case on camera.
Two tests, one question: does AI recommend the brand when the proof exists?
For each brand we took one creator video and wrote the shopper questions that creator had already answered on camera. Each question went to ChatGPT and Google AI Mode. Did AI name the brand the creator was vouching for?
For each brand we mapped what it wants to be recommended for, from bestsellers to brand values, and asked 13 to 17 real shopper questions in both engines. Who did AI recommend, and why?
A brand counts only when AI names it in the answer itself, not in a linked source, and once per answer. Every answer was logged, and every total was computed from the log.
Four patterns showed up in every segment.
Creators answered the exact question a shopper asks AI, on camera. Only 19% of those claims got the brand named. In the rest, AI named someone else or no one.
One laptop maker was named in 11 of 16 Google answers and 3 of 16 ChatGPT answers. Being found by one engine says little about the other.
AI listed one furniture brand’s best-selling pieces under the names of the stores that resell them. A golf retailer’s own pages were cited as the source while AI named its competitors.
AI misstated return guarantees, delivery cut-offs and store-brand histories, and credited one retailer’s next-day delivery to its competitor.
Each segment loses the recommendation in its own way.
Brands are anonymized. Scores are the number of AI answers that named the brand.
Named often, for the wrong reasons.
Retailers show up in AI answers, but as the deals site or the second choice. The programs that set them apart go missing.
Retailers and dupes get the credit.
Brands that sell mostly through retailers see AI recommend the store, the dupe or a bigger rival in their place.
Mostly invisible.
Without retailer pages or review volume to lean on, DTC brands are the easiest for AI to leave out.
See it brand by brand.
Eight brands, three of the questions we asked each one, and who AI named instead. Filter to find brands like yours.
AI won’t recommend what it can’t verify.
AI search builds answers from text it can read and trust: pages, feeds, reviews and structured data. Creator video looks like a blank space, and even when a claim is spoken clearly on camera, AI has no way to check it or tie it to the product a shopper is asking about. So it recommends the brands whose proof it can read.
How we ran the research
Engines and settings
Every question was asked once in Google AI Mode and once in ChatGPT, using signed-out or temporary, unpersonalized sessions so account history couldn’t shape the answers.
When and where
Answers were recorded in October and November 2026 from the US, except one UK retailer audit, where questions were asked for UK shoppers.
How brands were counted
A brand counts only when it is named in the answer text, once per answer. Ads, sponsored listings and linked sources alone don’t count.
Who was tested
Retailers, CPG brands that sell mostly through retailers, and DTC brands across beauty, wellness, fashion, home, electronics and sporting goods. The sample leans toward established brands with strong name recognition, so results for smaller brands are likely lower. Brands are anonymized in this report.
Two tests, reported separately
The creator-claim test (29 brands, 4 questions each) and the category audit (8 brands, 13 to 17 questions each) used different question sets, so their results are reported separately rather than combined into one rate.
A snapshot, not a ranking
AI answers vary by person, place and day. Treat these results as a snapshot of how AI answered at the time, not a fixed ranking.
See what AI is missing in your creator videos.
Pick one of your creator videos. We’ll break down every claim in it, ask AI the shopper questions it answers, and show you the proof AI is missing. Free, in 20 minutes.